Quoting Michael Kringe
accuracy to the book: 32/35 (Very accurate, but some dwarves have wrong colored beards and capes. I like that the elves disappear, pretty much like in the book); originality: 23/25 Very nice idea, this is a very difficult scene to make; creativity/technique: Some trees are a little bit blocky, but I don't understand why you think this is bad 28/30; minifigs: 6/10. (I don't like the caveman elf) All in all: 89/100! Great job!!
Wow I totally forgot about the contest! I was going for an Elrond look with the caveman elf :P