Although I agree that the flesh head does look unnatural for Hobbits, I prefer flesh to yellow so... I really like your MOCs and could you check out my Series sometime?

The flesh one was kinda creepy. I like the yellow one better, it looks good!

good job! for a person who uses yellow that's good for flesh. you should try and make a flesh fellowship then post. then i can see how good they look. honestly i think your flesh one is better.

Perfect torso, (will be appearing in my Movie accurate Pippin), and I like the yellow face better, mostly because the flesh one looks asian and demented. However the brown hair is a little too brown. Pippin's hair in the movie is a little on the red-brown side (Medium Dark Flesh on BrickLink). Athough there are few lego hairs that meet that criterion. But, if this is a Pippin from your imagination, than it is perfect. Great job!

The yellow head is the best! :D

Great Job! @Aidan, the torso looks exactly like his torso in the movie.

I like the yellow one better, but I can't figure out why.

I agree the flesh heads make LOTR look creepy. I don't have that torso though.

The clothes are too modern. The flesh face makes him look like a creepy dude. Try the torso of the cook in the POTC Queen anne's revenge.

Exactly the same as Marc. I really don't like the flesh heads as much as the yellow heads. The yellow one looks the best. Like William, the flesh head looks Asian.

I like the second minifig better. great head!

definitely yellow one, I really hate fleshy lego heads. never liked it. great pippin

Ha ha! Very nice. Not sure which is better though. :/ The yellow one is nice but the pale one's cool too. :P

I really like it. And yellow for sure, the fleshy one seems kind of Asian looking.