The waterfall: This is a really awesome design! I just love the way how you put the transparent and clear bricks together! (100/100). The minifigures: Arwen looks exactly like in the picture below! (100/100) Aragorn: His face doesn't suit him and the torso is also not the best choice (70/100). Your full score: (90/100)
I warned you! "Clearly based off movie..." Thats just a cover up, I bet Ian can't stand that scene, and even that one glance at the picture from the movie made him sick. ;)
Anyway, not my favorite scene either, but this is one of my favorite entries. 100/100
Quoting A Monkey
You could have done a bit more with this build. It seems rather simple...
Might seem simple, but you should try it. Fit a waterfall, greenery, a bridge and two minifigs on an 8x8 base with no stud overhang and find out how hard it would be to make this scene any more complicated. The simple look comes down to how well I pulled the task off. You might want to explain your comment :)
Now my mom is mad - my lunch is all over the new capret. :) I did not like this scene at all, but; of course we are not judging on the movie right! This is an awesome vignette. Though I agree with Max that this is the scene in the movie where we all look away. And I agree with Ru that if you were playing to your audience, you might have picked a different scene. Uh, I am droning on. I like the vignette though, and give it (from a purely LEGO perspective) 5 heads. Nice work!
BLAGH! THE KISSY PART!!! I NEED A BAG!!!! oops. Theres my prized immaturity kicking in. As Ru said, we usually resort to staring at a fascinating dent in the popcorn bowl, hearing nothing but the awesome music by Howard Shore. However, your scene is really cool by itself and I like it a lot.
If you were playing to the judges, then you would have seen they were all boys, and kept away from this scene. But if you were just trying to make an awesome vignette, with an awesome waterfall, then yeah, you should have made this.