Scenes: Excellent! You remembered them very well! They look excactly like in the movies! (I've seen them veeeeery often, and now I guess, that you also have much experience in them)(10/10). Bricks: You didn't use many different and everything looks a bit "brickish" (6/10). Minifigures: Lurtz deserves (9/10)(You used very good parts for him), but Saruman only (7/10), because the gray hair doesn't suit him. The forge is one of my favorite parts of the whole MOC. ( 8/10)
All in all: (80/100)
Quoting Max Pointner
That is really a clever Idea! As one of the judges, I must say that the creativity for this moc is great, and though the execution was a little off, they may just balance each other out.