One of the best Osgiliaths I've seen so far.

this is really good 5/5!!!!!

Awesome!

this is the best osgiliath i have seen!

Faramir was always one of my favourite characters and Osgiliath is a wonderfull place of ancient stories and tragedies. Great moc!!!

This is an awesome structure! I love your LOTR creations-so how will we ask them to judge?

Nice!

yeeah i like LEGOlas :D

Good job! Like the minifigs.

i really like this. i tried building Osgiliath, i thought it was okay. but yours definitely dwarfs the 'greatness' of mine. and Frodo looks rather angry. haha

I love the building designs. This is my favorite scene from movie 3 and think you nailed it. I like the archer in the window. Great Job.

Brilliant creation, this bit was my favorite scene and you absolutely nailed it!

This is one of my favorite scenes from LOTR, I like the design of the buildings. 5/5

Die Ruinen hast du gut getroffen!!

brilliant design, i like it very much. 8.5/10

Spectacular MOC! It looks just like the movie! Now I want to reread the books and watch the movies again!

Like what Dirk said, we rarely see LOTR MOCs here on MOCpages. Considering they're so rare, I'm giving you 5 points. ~Ryan

Great rendition, pleasant surprise, we see too few LOTR creations on mocpages.

Pretty nice execution, though I would like to see more rubble, on the streets and in heaps. I'm also questioning the hobbit designs. Still, the scenery said 'Osgiliath' to me before I even saw the full image. Very nice.

this is awesome. best osgiliath i've seen.

Good work i liked the angeld wall!

nice ruins. i really didn't like that scene. the knights of gondor were so stupid. they knew the orcs were coming and then they let the orcs land and waited for half the army to get past before leaping out and attacking the middle of the orc horde. because of that stupid idea they were surrounded by orcs right from the begining, when they could have just shot some fire arrows into the boats when the orcs were in the middle of the river, or just plain old arrows if they didn't have fire. it bothers me every time that the awesome warriors of gondor would do something so dumb. anyway, great moc, the ruins are the best part!

Nice work on the ruins! We need more good LOR MOCS. You captured the scene very well here.

Nice one. Very ruiney. I like the shots looking through all the busted walls. see ya. garth

Excellent! This is one of my favorite scenes :) My only advice is to add Smeagol and a dead archer.

Huh, Frodo nicht glücklich scheinen, tut er? Gute Moc, hat es eine Menge Details. Halten Sie sich die gute Arbeit! :)

Nicely done, good job with the ruins

Ja ich wollte gerade das selbe schreiben! ;-) Ach und das mit den Helmen ist ein problem das ich auch immer wieder habe, dass Photoshop Teile wegschneidet weil sie glänzen. Das ist echt nervig!

Sehr schön anzusehn! Da bekommt man grad mal wieder Laune sich alle drei Filme am Stück reinzuziehn (in der Extended...oO)! - Kevin